“Toner” Shoes Attracting Bad Press

June 30, 2010 at 2:15 PM · 2 comments

in Gadgetry,Meanderings

You’ve heard about these shoes, probably from co-workers or friends, and you’ve most likely been massively bombarded (some would even consider “over-bombarded”) by advertising by the companies peddling them. These are those “shaper” or “toner” or “exerciser” shoes that were initially promising to turn you into a world-class athlete by… walking.

There was an inordinately large flood of patients coming to the office within the first few weeks of the products’ releases, a few months ago. People who previously did well in their regular exercise routines were complaining about conditions like plantar fasciitis (arch and/or heel pain), Achilles tendinitis, posterior tibialis tendinitis or dysfunction, ankle sprains, etc. Fortunately, as consumers have gotten wiser about these shoes, the flood has diminished to a small stream.

Apparently, news about some of the adverse effects of these shoes has made it into the mainstream, like in USA Today online. There now appears to be a caveat emptor attitude surrounding the purchase of these shoes, and some brands actually supply customers with an instruction book to guide them on how to properly use the shoes. This being the case, these shoes should most likely be avoided by casual walkers or joggers; instead, if you are curious about them, having a frank discussion with your podiatrist or physician about the various types of rocker-bottom and negative-angled shoegear available, over-the-counter and by prescription, would be a good way to start, along with designing an initial exercise program and diet management.

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

1 HxC July 27, 2010 at 4:21 AM

TONER SHOES: Some of the advertising used to shuck (especially) the Sketchers & Reeboks was so outrageous– it started to make me wonder- the people who have college degrees who fell for this gimmick- should their Alma maters be discredited? Add to that they look so effing UGLY- I’ll let my call to nationally syndicated talk show host Dr. Dean say the rest:
http://soundcloud.com/handcancel/whats-the-deal-with-toner-shoes-my-call-to-dr-dean

Reply

2 Steve August 2, 2010 at 10:36 AM

If you examine the Skechers vs. the Reeboks, you’ll notice that the construction is different: the former has contouring that resembles rockerbottom shoes but with placement of the breaks at different locations, while the latter resembles mini balance balls. The effects are different for the wearers, but introduce a lot of instability in general. Note that both brands provide some literature with “careful” instructions… a cautionary thing.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: